Chivas USA Crush Dynamo, Next Two Matches Will Decide the Season
For the second straight year, it's July and the Houston Dynamo's season is on the brink of collapse. After a disastrous 3-0 ass kicking at the hands of Chivas USA last night, Houston now sit on the outside if the playoff picture with two games ahead that very well could decide the fate of the season.
Nothing really went right last night and in all honesty, it was a 90 minute microcosm of the Dynamo's entire season. The defense was a mess making countless decision and positional mistakes, the midfield was unable to hold possession and generate any movement forward and the forwards couldn't hit the side of a barn wall. Oh yeah, Tally Hall was solid but completely hung out to dry on multiple occasions.
It's the exact type of play we've become accustomed to over the past season and a half and despite all the roster changes and generic coach-speak, nothing has actually changed.
The Dynamo are a hot mess, a roster built of individually talented players that for some reason are unable to get on the same page and play as a team. Whether it's the actual case or not, the blame lands at the feet of Dominic Kinnear who is ultimately responsible for the results on the field. Am I calling for Kinnear's head? Not yet, but I'm damn close. Which really sucks, because I like Kinnear but there's a classic sports cliche that seems to fit right not...you can't fire the players.
With a new stadium on the way and a lot of money on the line in terms of corporate and fan money, the Dynamo are essentially in a full crisis and Chris Canetti is going to really start feeling the pressure to get things figured out.
In the meantime, there are two ridiculously vital game in the next two weeks. The Dynamo welcome the Sounders to Robertson and then travel to PPL Park to face the Philadelphia Union. It's six points Houston must have and six points I have no faith in them being able to get. Barring a tremendous turn around, I fully expect to be writing the obituary for the 2011 Houston Dynamo on August 7th.
Let's face at, right now, this team sucks.
48 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
You may not be able to "fire" the players...
But you sure as hell can release them and find something somewhere that is better. I didn’t get to see most of the match last night due to eye infections and being unable to wear contacts for the next week or so (I did find an old pair of glasses I can wear in the interim though, woo).
Based on what I could see, we looked beat from the start. The better team won, and as a fan of the Dynamo that is very hard to swallow. We’re a week into the summer transfer window and so far we have Moffat to show for it. The team had better put something into their DP search now before it’s too late.
Also, get rid of the excess weight. Guys like Watson simply don’t cut it as starters on a team vying for the playoffs. Something tells me we’ll be hearing news of some more trialists this coming week, none of which will make a huge difference either way. I don’t expect a DP signing until it’s simply too late.
-- "...I was sick, napping, and then woke up and came to the computer to read a note from the Gingered Angel of Doom..." Martek - Dynamo Theory Blog
Ninja please
I don’t want to hear about these trialists from a 2nd Division Nicaraguan team or 1st Division team in Antigua. Please bring in someone from a lower-mid-to-mid-to-upper table team in the first division of a quality league like Argentina, Brazil or Mexico or maybe even a European league. But seriously, the FO needs to step their game up and do it now.
Watson sucks balls...
The ONLY positive signing we got in the off season was Taylor…that’s it. As for Watson some fans didn’t want him in the Dynamo in the first place (I’m one of them). My gut was telling me this player will make the team shit and not produce at all. He didn’t even try doing something positive for our team. He’s just taking up space and money. When Dixon came in I was impressed with his play. This kid has skills and speed but dumbass Kinnear doesn’t play him enough. Moffat looked ok too wheh he came in. WE NEED BONIEK GARCIA ASAP! Now this guy will make Watson his bitch and keep him on the bench or get rid of the trash!
Garcia is projected as a Winger right now
I do believe. This wouldn’t solve our problems, not in the least.
-- "...I was sick, napping, and then woke up and came to the computer to read a note from the Gingered Angel of Doom..." Martek - Dynamo Theory Blog
Really?
A winger is the least of our problems. When is Kinnear going to use his head? We need a CAM, not a RM
It might be...
a case where the opportunity presented itself and we had to act now because others may scoop him up. We all know we need a CAM, but wouldn’t we also kick ourselves if we could’ve picked up a great winger and passed on it? I would pray that the FO doesn’t think Garcia cures all our ills because that’s not the case at all. IF we find a great, DP-level CAM then grabbing Garcia becomes a signing that can really make us a contender because we’d have great defenders, a winger that can really attack defenses, forwards, good role-playing midfielders and a CAM pulling all the strings.
But does it do so this season?
-- "...I was sick, napping, and then woke up and came to the computer to read a note from the Gingered Angel of Doom..." Martek - Dynamo Theory Blog
(gulp)
that, dear Fuze, is the multi-million dollar question. Personally, if we find that right couple of signings then I think we can finish the season on a high note. I think we just miss the playoffs but pick up more wins along the way and finish strong. I do hope I’m wrong, but we’re basing a playoff scenario on the fact that we find a high-quality CAM and can get Garcia on a loan deal (or the like) and maybe find a speedy forward from around the league (not named Oduro). Assuming we can do that in the next 3 weeks then I still think we just miss but finish strong because it does take time to integrate and we would take another 2-3 weeks to do that. But I would gladly take a strong finish rather than limping along knowing that we still have gaps to fill (in other words, staying as we are).
The integration time is what I look at most.
At this point, we should all count this season as lost and demand they make moves toward the future of the organization. Right now, I’m perfectly content to call this season a rebuilding season and hope the FO treats the remainder of the season as such.
Otherwise I feel we miss out on the opportunities this transfer window may have in terms of a short term vs long term mindset. Which I’ll admit is a damned shame. I hate to see a chance at an MLS Cup go to waste, but if it means another year of rebuilding, by GOD let’s move forward not backward or stay stagnant.
-- "...I was sick, napping, and then woke up and came to the computer to read a note from the Gingered Angel of Doom..." Martek - Dynamo Theory Blog
(Le Sigh)
I’m really trying to hold out hope of a magical turn of events and a mad dash to the playoffs but its looking more likely that we may soon be out of the running. But like you said, as long as the FO makes moves that point to a long-term solution then I’m very cool with it as well. I’d much rather that than a panic signing to try and salvage the season and it costs us flexibility to address our long-term issues
Keep holding out
That’s the sign of a true fan, bro.
-- "...I was sick, napping, and then woke up and came to the computer to read a note from the Gingered Angel of Doom..." Martek - Dynamo Theory Blog
I disagree completely
Watson is a quality player. His control of the ball, footwork, movement, and vision is excellent. Right now the team sucks so he doesn’t look good. and he can get frustrated.
Also Dixon has not impressed me…yet. Actually he has, because he’s young, but compared to other players he has a ways to go before breaking into the starting 18 and before he gets more playing time.
I'm having trouble with this team
I don’t know what it is…..we have quality players (we do really) but we are just in a funk. Our defense is pretty deep, we have a few holes in midfield but overall it isn’t terrible, and our forwards are good at holding the ball up and good at scoring when given the chance, yet possession is our enemy.
Let’s hope we snap out of this funk one way or another…a good DP signing would be nice hopefully to fill in a certain hole in midfield.
Coach or players?
I don’t know Gribbs…we’ve seen this malaise over the course of the season and its hard to tell if its a team attitude, certain players or just simply a disconnect between players and coach. I just know that even when you’re not on the same page or outclassed, you can still try and its that lack of effort that disgusts me more than anything. It at least appears to fans that you give a toss, and that does count for something in our collective book.
Too often we look complacent
I agree. I don’t know if it’s a matter of motivation, but too often (and this goes for all sports, teams, and players) that just don’t seem to have as Ching put it, “fight”. Who knows. We looked great at the beginning of the season and it has since May came around we have looked like crap. I can’t put my finger on any one reason why – it is too easy for us to say well we don’t have a true CAM, or point to one player (Watson is the fall man in this thread) and say it is their fault. That is all bullshit. It’s a team sport and it takes a team to win games and lose games. Good players improve not only score sheets, but players around them.
I was pissed off last night and still am. We need some kind of signing to make our good players, great players, and we need to show some fight.
Chicken or the egg
I agree that its frustrating as hell to watch the team because we know what they can do and we have seen them fight, so why is it that they have these games where they seem to just roll over before the game even starts? I mean yes, having an impact player at the CAM could loosen guys up and take the pressure off them, plus honestly a good CAM makes everyone look better and so you play better. But do we need to depend on that to at least play hard? That’s where I call bull$hit on the players and team…we all know we need help and where we need but you can still gut out the effort until then. Your last sentence summarizes thing to a tee: an impact signing can make our players really shine, but until that white knight comes riding in we still have a job to do so let’s go out and do it
From the Department of the Glass-Half-Full...
I’ve been quietly hoping for this to happen for the last couple of weeks and here’s why: for about 5-6 weeks we’ve been able to eek out a couple of points, maybe grab 3, lose a couple and since we’re in the East we’re still reasonable in the mix, at least on paper. It’s given time to experiment with positions, formations, and for the FO they can bring in trialists and whatnot and all appears to be moving in the right direction.
The Emperor has no clothes now. This game exposed us, warts and all. Ginge said it exceptionally well: we’re a collection of talented individuals but without a vision, without direction and in some cases, without a cause or clue.
With this result, we must take action. And I don’t mean bring in some trialist from the first division in Belize, I mean we have to make a serious move. I had hoped that Watson could be a serviceable (not great) CAM to buy us time but I’m starting to have doubts. The CAM has to set the tone for the team and making silly challenges and getting shown red when you play such a critical role makes me really question things. And in the thread that Fuze started about our scenarios, I (and I believe) others started making the case that we must start bringing in Academy products and giving them minutes. Because what are we doing now? This puts us firmly against the wall to get at least 9 points in the next 3-4 games. If we can’t then the season is over, its plain and simple.
Getting Garcia would be a real boost, and while I know he’s not going to solve our problems its one of those situations where if the opportunity presents itself you have to take it. But once again I will reiterate what we all know: WE NEED A CENTRAL ATTACKING MIDFIELDER. I realize they don’t grow on trees and getting a quality one who wants to come here and sign for within what we’re allowed to spend (whatever that may be) is a tough ask, but its what needs to happen. So get it done, Canetti, its your job. As Ginge pointed out, is this how we want to go in to next season, in to a new stadium: limping and gasping and falling apart? As for Kinnear, I love the guy and I’ve always been in his corner but he has got to start thinking outside of the box on this with either bringing Academy kids in or dropping people from the starting XI or something because its the coach’s job to get the talent you have to perform, plain and simple.
Gribbsy is right, we are actually a couple of critical pieces from turning around but those pieces are huge gaping ones. I would’ve said it was a funk (and I believe I did) a few games ago but this seems to be indicative of something else. Even when you’re in a funk you can show spirit and fight, and I’m not seeing that. Above all it scares me more than anything because a talented team without heart is a team destined to fail when it counts. I’m not sure how you fix that.
. It’s a frustrating position to be in as a fan who loves this team so much. We’re on the cusp of doing great things or also on the point of imploding. So much is riding on the next couple of weeks that I hope that we find a way to get it right, otherwise its going to be a very, very long offseason.A lot of it is momentum
We’re letting the losses pile and when they do it becomes a burden and can put people mentally in a hole where the players don’t show up to play. The All-Star game could energize some players, but will it help? We’ll see, but it probably won’t be enough.
We aren’t up against the ropes though..we’re 2 points shy of a playoff position. That being said we are up against the ropes because even if we make the playoffs we’re not poised to compete when (if?) we get there.
I love this team to death, and I love the players, but it is getting frustrating to watch. If we can take it to the Sounders then we can take it to anybody. I hope we take it to them because I hate the Sounders and Montero more than any other player in the league. Time for a turn around Dynamo!
Amen to that
Me and a few others of the Naranjariat have discussed it that while we could make the playoffs, as currently constructed we would be first-round fodder even if we did make it. It’s not bad but its not great, it puts us just outside of the mid-table teams but not in the contenders or elite. I really hope we can find an impact CAM, hopefully sign a winger like Garcia and then find a speedy forward to play off our bigger target men. I really am hoping we can pull it off because if we can the future is so bright for us
Dom
It seems to me that dom is making a lot of these decisions you’re asking for. He dropped Freeman for prince kofi, Palmer for cam, boss for Taylor. I think he’s done just about the best with the current personnel that we got. As for dixon he seems a bit inconsistent, every other time I see him play I get an opposite impression, last night he had a good deal of giveaways like 4 or 5 in the ten minutes he played, that is pretty poor for a sub to do.
by Futbol anonymous on Jul 24, 2011 9:39 PM CDT via mobile up reply actions
Fair points
But again, part of that was switching personnel and positions every other game. I understand why you try to do that but at some point you have to find a rotation and stick with it for at least a couple of games. For a while there it was like a game of whack-a-mole.
And while I do agree that he is trying to field a competitive team with what we have, the part I was getting at is that the coach’s job to try and get the guys out there to play. I do understand the other half of that equation is that it is the player’s responsibility…I’m a personal believer that at this level a coach shouldn’t have to be responsible to fire you up every week to play your best but maybe that is the case and Dom is assuming they’ll go out there. I don’t know. Part of the blase showing has been uncertainty at position and those positional responsibilities but part of it could also simply be attitude. It’s hard to tell at this point.
And as Fuze pointed out, if the season goes tit$-up in the next couple of weeks then start bringing in the Academy kids. Sure, they might make mistakes and might get exposed but they will need to face the competition at some point if we’re trying to integrate them into the squad. Because at that point who cares if they make mistakes because its not like we’re playing for the playoffs (again, this is assuming that our poor/inconsistent play continues and we move further from the playoff hunt).
They didn't tell you?
Dom reads DT.com every night after practice for ideas. Totally.
-- "...I was sick, napping, and then woke up and came to the computer to read a note from the Gingered Angel of Doom..." Martek - Dynamo Theory Blog
Also
Wow, I’ve made my opinions on Ashe known for some time and he’s started to win me over the last couple of games but yeah, I think my gut was right on this one. I understand why we try him at LB but this continues to fuel my distrust of him at that position. I hope its not the case where I have to use my (well-despised) saying amongst my wife and kids, “I don’t like to be right, I just am”
Backe would disagree with your assesment of Ashe
I think Ashe has flourished at LB. For me RB has been the big question mark of the season for defense. Freeman had stretches that looked good and stretches that looked just terrible. Same thing goes for Sarkodie. Also our CB tandem has been inconsistent despite our depth at the position. Hainault has been solid but I think he may do us better if he shifts to RB and allow either a Boswell/Taylor pairing or Boswell/Cameron.
Hmmm
Flourished is a strong word and I wouldn’t necessarily pair that with Ashe’s play at LB this season. Inconsistent is the word for me…and likely Backe’s inclusion of Ashe is due to his speed (much as his inclusion of Cameron is likely due to his prior play at CB plus the fact that he is a “utility” player that can come in handy at several spots. Both back spots have been inconsistent this year but I know that we are trying to groom Sarkodie as the RB of the future for our team, so I’m willing to give him more slack there. It’s not to say I don’t like Ashe or what he can bring, but its reminiscent of our “experiments” with Cameron this year at different positions; Ashe is formerly a midfielder who we are using as a LB. I’m just saying that while I understand why he’s there he’s still inconsistent and I wonder if we should continue using him there. Hainault has been stout at CB but I’m not sure we’d want to move him to RB when he’s been so good there; I could only imagine moving him there if we’re going to make Moffat the DM and move Cameron back to CB to pair him with Taylor or Boswell (though I think Boz is going to be shipped out sooner rather than later)
Speculation time...
If Cameron is said to have come to the Dynamo as a Right Midfielder, is it plausible he could perhaps play RB? He’d be a hell of a defensive asset along that side with his speed and defensive ability. I don’t know, the more I think about it, the more I personally like it. That’s just me though.
-- "...I was sick, napping, and then woke up and came to the computer to read a note from the Gingered Angel of Doom..." Martek - Dynamo Theory Blog
Interesante
in our little Candyland/Speculation feature I believe I had Cameron playing on the right (RM) because I know he had experience…or I might be thinking of the trade thread where we talked about moving him there. I dunno, it was something like that. In any event, I think he could play RB but what happens to Sarkodie? Do we try converting him to LB to replace Ashe? We could try that because he’s still so young that we could at least try that..because yes, Cameron does have the speed and defensive prowess as well as some midfield ability (passing) and can cross it up if he were to overlap with the RM. But would we ever try it? I doubt it considering all that’s happening plus since we’ve had Cameron in like 4 different positions now….bless that boy, he is a resilient one for the fact that he keeps doing what is asked of him, regardless of what it is.
If we put him at RM, he could be the perfect utility guy for the USMNT
And after what happened against Mexico…a utility defender might be just what the team needs.
-- "...I was sick, napping, and then woke up and came to the computer to read a note from the Gingered Angel of Doom..." Martek - Dynamo Theory Blog
My post was supposed to say RB, not RM...
Uber fail. For shame for shame.
-- "...I was sick, napping, and then woke up and came to the computer to read a note from the Gingered Angel of Doom..." Martek - Dynamo Theory Blog
Sunday night
at 9:30, I think we let that slide ;-)
Though you know, we could always try that….
/slinks back into the shadows
Might be an improvement over what we've been pushing out there on that side anyways
-- "...I was sick, napping, and then woke up and came to the computer to read a note from the Gingered Angel of Doom..." Martek - Dynamo Theory Blog
Oh and 9:30 is nothing for me...
I work regularly til midnight. And I’m applying to work overnights which is 10p – 6a. Gotta love work from home!
-- "...I was sick, napping, and then woke up and came to the computer to read a note from the Gingered Angel of Doom..." Martek - Dynamo Theory Blog
RB would be interesting
Sarkodie can still grow as a sub/reserve. Right now we need to field the best possible lineup.
I think it'd be a worthwhile experiment
We could give him the rest of the season and see how he adjusts. The rest of it is lost at this point anyways.
-- "...I was sick, napping, and then woke up and came to the computer to read a note from the Gingered Angel of Doom..." Martek - Dynamo Theory Blog
True, however...
do we keep experimenting at the cost of playing time for Sarkodie? Again, if he is part of our future, to me at least we should be giving him more exposure to league play…but of course if we are playing the experiment card then move Cameron to RB and Sarkodie to LB and dangle Ashe as trade bait. Sell high while we can claim he’s an All-Star. That way we could have Boz & Ashe as trade chips that can really get something quality in return (like say, a forward with speed)
Sarkodie's young.
He’s got a couple of seasons to learn as a sub. Hell, this is the first time EVER Dom has STARTED two rookie’s from the SuperDraft in the SAME season. Come on, that’s not Dom’s style.
-- "...I was sick, napping, and then woke up and came to the computer to read a note from the Gingered Angel of Doom..." Martek - Dynamo Theory Blog
1 Kenny Cooper to go...
With a side of allocation money? After his last showing in Portland, they might be more willing to part with him now.
-- "...I was sick, napping, and then woke up and came to the computer to read a note from the Gingered Angel of Doom..." Martek - Dynamo Theory Blog
Don't be so quick to panic and experiment
Cameron at Right Back was something I’ve long been calling for. At the very least put him at right mid, but at this point would we be better off further weakening center midfield for the sake of taking away minutes of a promising but mistake prone young defender? Cameron may not be great at center midfield but the troubling fact still remains that he is our best center midfielder. Is it logical to bash on Watson then go on to debate on a scenario in which he would be forced to play with only Dixon as backup? What then would happen to Defensive midfield? Is everybody so eager to bash our performance that nobody wishes to step forward and critique the play of the heir apparent of defensive midfield. It seems to me that Kinnear has backtracked Cameron since his belief that he could be great at attacking midfield. The move for Moffat in my opinion was for somebody who Kinnear believes can take control of defensive midfield. When you take that information and add on that we’ve been “actively searching” for an attacking midfielder I think Kinnear wants to retreat Cameron all the way to CB. What worries me is that as fans we should be the ones watching players like Moffat and be constructive for our club not be so quick to abandon ship. On that note, it should be noted that Moffat looked lost in midfield. He did no tracking, didn’t cover any passing lanes and worst of didn’t even look to pressure the ball 5 feet in front of him he just kept jogging. Many times he was caught behind the run of play. If I’m remotely correct about this whole thing than don’t expect much from him for 90 minutes against Seattle. Rosales will have a field day.
Don’t be down on the the Dynamo. Sure its easy to look at the standings and get a bit depressed but the FO isn’t the problem. Be proud you support the Dynamo after all how many clubs can say they have more MLS Cups than us.
by foreverorange25 on Jul 24, 2011 11:30 PM CDT via mobile reply actions
By my count?
2
-- "...I was sick, napping, and then woke up and came to the computer to read a note from the Gingered Angel of Doom..." Martek - Dynamo Theory Blog
But that's neither the point nor the concern
The concern IS long-term. I consider this season as of this moment a complete wash. We experimented with Cameron, with Koke, with others, and it’s yielded the wrong results. It has us pointed the wrong direction. Instead of pushing to improve before the end of the season, my goal, my hope, is to see this club gearing for the future. Yes, that means moving Cameron to wherever he can fit in for next season and beyond. We’re stacked at CB, and I’m NOT a fan of usurping Hainault or Taylor there.
I am a fan, however, of usurping a rookie who has a good 2-3 seasons to develop at the MLS level. As I said previously Dom isn’t the coach who brings guys in early, so it bewilders me why he brought in HRH this early in his career. Yes, we want a youth movement, but not at the expense of a player’s confidence. And we’ve seen what broken confidence can do to a player.
In short, I’m not suggesting moving Cameron as a means to an ends, but an ends to a means. We have to figure something out for the future for him, or we need to use him as trade bait. It’s not worth keeping him stifled in a spot that I honestly believe Moffat will fill in time. You don’t take a player off one team and supplant him on another and expect immediate results. Didn’t happen for Henry or Angel, won’t happen with Moffat who is far lesser than either.
-- "...I was sick, napping, and then woke up and came to the computer to read a note from the Gingered Angel of Doom..." Martek - Dynamo Theory Blog
That was...
Rhetorical. DC and LA? I’m pretty sure those are the two.
by foreverorange25 on Jul 25, 2011 2:31 AM CDT via mobile up reply actions
Crash and burn
The players do not have confidence in doms tactics verses a 5 man midfield. we did not match up in the midfield and the players did not play hard. Dom changes vs KC but does not try to match up against the goats. Dom refuses to change and its hurting him and his team.
Blaming Dom?
I refuse to think our problem lies with Kinnear. By the sounds of it he does plenty of short passing drills and tries to incorporate passing drills into practice but if you take a second to look on the field nobody wants the ball. Part of the reason the backline just kicks it amongst themselves is because in the midfield specifically central midfield refuses to show for the ball. They stand there and watch whoever has the ball. The few times they do receive the ball they are poor in distribution to actually start the attack. Not only do we not have anybody linking the midfield and defense we also lack anyone who can capably link defense and midfield.
by foreverorange25 on Jul 25, 2011 2:26 AM CDT via mobile up reply actions
Oops, I did it again!
I don’t think our big singing would necessarily have to be in CAM. A quality DM would do. Basically, we need someone to control the heartbeat and pace of the game, making sure that favors our style of play, while playing balls to dangerous positions either through slow buildups or fast transitions. While a true 10 would be a Godsend, they are pretty hard to find, with our financial and league limitations.
I feel we would benefit just as much from a DM in the Edgar Davids or Shalrie Joseph mold (in his prime- just don’t drug test him!). I think back to some of the dynasty teams- DC United with Ritchie Williams who was more gadfly harrier but effective paired with El Diablo, or Joseph with the Rev feeding Ralston on the wing or Twellman up top. One of my faves was Armas for the Fire who was a pre-injury destroyer. I still believe the USMNT would have gone farther in the WC if he hadn’t had his disabilitating injury. Armas was a bulldog, disrupting opponent’s flow to the Nth degree.
We had Palmer @ DM, now we have Cameron and still we are theorizing flip flopping him around. Hell, he was All MLS @ CB. Right now, in terms of awesomeness, we have Hall, sometimes Davis (when not completely shut down by opponents), and no one else.
Awesomeness is not something to screw with. It should be revered, treasured, and coveted. Instead we keep trying to unsuccessfully make this awesomeness interchangable to several positions as if awesomeness is a math equation and positions are intechangable X’s and Y’s. Like converting currency, each exchange takes a little or a lot out of the total, often very costly. Cameron is a perfect example of this.
Here is where I bang my head against the wall as the Dynamo mirror the struggles of the USMNT. Why can we not play to our best players strengths? Why must one of our best players play with one foot tied behind his back because it’s best for the team?
I’d like to know how many foreign slots are left and who is currently holding a slot on the roster. Taylor was a nice find, but should foreign slots be reserved for possible impact players- not positions where we have a lot of depth? Garcia would be an impact signing, but we need more.
My vote- look for a CAM, DM, quick forward with proven goal scoring ability and anyone else who significantly upgrades the roster (Garcia). As far as winning the next few games, I’m not sure what sneaking into the playoffs will do for us. The kiss of doom was our 2009 playoff run where we were a phantom call in regular time from going to the finals. This gave the aura of awesomeness- enough so the FO did not replace Holden and Clark adequately- instead relying on Mulrooney’s legs (which had busted the odometer by then- chug chug chug) and last minute who the hell is he and what has he done tryouts, producing just traded Palmer .
I kept asking Martek- “what the $@#%^&* is the plan?”
Now, we are beginning to see the fruits of the lack of plan. Given our mostly conservative FO, it will take some time to turn this battleship. Even worse, after paying Landin far too much to hang out @ All You Can Eat Buffets, our owners are a little financially gun shy, which translated into the FO having little rope to make mistakes.
I believe, to make this pain meaningful, we’re gonna have to either junk the season now or make an incredible signing before the transfer window closes. Given the progressive and risk taking nature of our beloved FO (HAR HAR HAR- kick me in the side to make me stop), I think it’s time to start planning for 2012-2013.
So you'd elect to run with a 3-man rotation at CB?
Taylor-Cameron or Hainault-Cameron with any of three seeing significant bench time or using the rotation to keep all three fresh. Cameron at CB does NOT help Cameron. Yes, he’s an All-Star at the position because he is pretty darned good there, but I believe that’s based on his speed and recovery time more so than any other factor. We do not know Cameron’s full potential anywhere.
I do not understand this hypothesis that moving a player around, expanding his skillset, diminishes his specific level of play at any one position. I think playing him in an attacking role hurt him a lot, but there is a vast difference in skillset between offense and defense players, period. There is a far less “diminishing returns model” on a guy who plays DMid versus CB, or CB vs LB/RB. Some CBs don’t play outside back positions not because they can’t, but because usually the guys on offense on the outsides are burners (ala Cruz). Most CBs in the league who are true CBs do not have superb speed, they recover and can change pace quickly. They rely mostly on strength to shutdown the advance via tackles or just plain taking the ball back by physical force.
Cameron isn’t that physical style CB. He relies on his recovery speed to make adjustments on the fly, and thus to me he’d be much better on the outside anyways. Especially the more I consider it. I am also plenty sure Dom has experimented during practices and scrimmages and has not liked what he’s seen somewhere at some point with Cameron. We all assumed Cameron moving up to CAM was out of need, not out of choice. But what if it was done by Dom’s choice because he did see something we can’t or couldn’t have seen because it was in practices? Even still, I’m glad the Cam at CAM experiment is concluded. Yes, this comment kinda ended full circle, so sue me…
-- "...I was sick, napping, and then woke up and came to the computer to read a note from the Gingered Angel of Doom..." Martek - Dynamo Theory Blog
Tired of experimenting
No, I guess I’m saying I think if we’re going to keep Cameron, we need to put him where he’s best. While Cameron doesn’t over rely on physicality (Robinson/Hainault), he definitely isn’t soft. I think he’s an improvement over Taylor and gives us a dimension @ CB we don’t have with the Taylor/Hainault tandem- a passing CB who can transition the team into the attack quickly.
I DO think Cameron @ CB does help Cameron as he seems to excel with less responsibility. He brings a unique skill set to CB I think helps us immensely, especially in an area where we are so poor (the Houston Dynamo- from 0-60 mph in 70 minutes and only if down by a couple of goals).
If Cameron was @ CAM out of need, it would show that Dom is aware it’s not a fit, so you’d think that after over a year and a half, we’d look try to sign someone of benefit. So we got Obodai and Watson. And have tried Cruz 2.0, Lindemann…
BFD.
BTW- I’d be happy if Cameron was All MLS 11 @ any other position. I just want to know how long we wait THIS time.
by playtherapy on Jul 25, 2011 10:27 AM CDT up reply actions














